Skip to content
An empty, sunlit secondary school classroom with an open laptop and exercise book on the teacher's desk

Helping schools make informed decisions about AI

AI is changing how students learn, how teachers work and what schools can reasonably infer from the work students produce. A student may produce an impressive piece of work without developing the knowledge or skills the task was intended to teach. AI may help teachers provide feedback more efficiently, but does that feedback help students improve?

For school leaders, the challenge is deciding what these changes mean for their school and what, if anything, needs to change.

Decisions in Practice helps school leadership teams understand what AI changes, make informed decisions and translate those decisions into workable practice. The starting point is what your school is trying to achieve, not how it can use more AI.

Independent advice. School-specific recommendations. Practical next steps.

Why AI decisions can feel overwhelming

The challenge isn't finding information. It's knowing which advice to trust, what applies to your school and whether any action is needed.

  • Media headlines
  • Online discussion
  • Official guidance
  • Other schools
  • EdTech suppliers

What AI changes

AI can improve the quality of a student's work without necessarily improving their understanding. It can help students complete tasks while removing opportunities to develop the very knowledge and skills those tasks were designed to teach.

For example, a school might allow students to use AI to plan essays but require them to write independently. If the aim is to develop students' ability to construct and organise an argument, AI may already be performing an important part of the learning. Students could follow expectations perfectly yet those expectations might still undermine the educational purpose.

Are any of these questions on your leadership agenda?

We know AI is affecting homework. What should we actually change?

What does completed homework tell the school about students' understanding? Which knowledge and skills do students need to demonstrate independently?

Staff and students are using AI differently. What expectations make sense?

Does AI-assisted feedback help students learn, or simply make feedback quicker to produce? Which expectations would be helpful and workable?

We're considering investing in AI. Will it really solve our problem?

What should improve for staff or students? Would AI training or software solve the underlying problem, or could a simpler approach work better?

We've read the guidance, but how do we reach a decision?

Changing advice and conflicting examples can become overwhelming. Leadership time is limited and unresolved questions slip down the agenda.

You don't need another pile of information. You need to know what it means for your school and what to do next.

How Decisions in Practice can help

Start with the support that fits your situation. These are not compulsory stages.

Understand

AI: Don't Panic

Save time wading through AI updates. This leadership session builds a shared understanding of significant changes, helping your team prioritise immediate questions and recognise what can wait. Not generic AI training or a product demonstration.

Explore the leadership session

Decide

School AI Approach Review

The flagship service. Bring one AI-related question your school needs to resolve. Decisions in Practice researches the relevant guidance and evidence, examines what's happening in your school and compares realistic options, including how they would affect staff and students. Your school receives a clear, school-specific recommendation, practical next steps and proportionate ways to check whether the decision is working.

Explore the Approach Review

Put into practice

From decision to practice

Make an agreed decision workable without creating unnecessary tasks. Separately scoped, optional follow-on help can clarify expectations, communication or selected guidance, focused on the practical changes your school needs.

Discuss follow-on support

Beyond "use it or ban it"

Educational purpose comes first, not a pro-AI or anti-AI position. The question is what the school is trying to achieve and which response is most likely to help. That might mean using AI selectively, changing existing practice, choosing a simpler approach or deciding that no immediate change is needed.

Ofsted does not inspect AI as a separate topic or expect schools to adopt particular tools. Where AI is relevant, its focus is on the quality of leaders' decisions, what they considered and the impact on students. Simply saying that teachers 'retain professional judgement' does not explain what that means in practice or how the school knows it is happening.

From educational purpose to practical decisions

The question is not simply whether students should be allowed to use AI. It is whether AI supports or undermines what they are supposed to learn. The answer may differ between subjects, activities and stages of learning.

The aim is not for every teacher to do the same thing, but for teachers to apply consistent educational reasoning. This is one example of how Decisions in Practice helps schools translate educational priorities into practical decisions about AI.

Should students use AI for this activity?

What is the student supposed to learn?
Would AI perform the thinking or skill the student needs to develop?

Yes

Protect independent practice

Restrict or structure AI assistance

No

Consider the educational benefit

Permit AI assistance where justified

How will we establish whether the intended learning has actually taken place?
Set clear expectations and identify appropriate evidence
AI use must also reflect relevant safeguarding, accessibility, data protection and assessment requirements.

Founded by a former Assistant Headteacher with experience of teaching, learning, assessment and school leadership.

Independent of suppliers and the assumed solution. No commission, no products to sell and no presumption that more AI use is better.

Evidence separated from marketing. Guidance, research and commentary weighed for what they really show.

Facing an AI decision?

Discuss the question your school needs to resolve before committing time or resources. Start with a free, no-obligation conversation.

Discuss your question